Production Blog
Dan Davidson DTN Agronomist

Thursday 02/04/10

SCN leads to Triple Whammy

Dean Malvick, plant pathologist at the University of Minnesota speaking the Soybean Symposium told the audience that SCN can influence the outbreak of BSR (brown stem rot) and SDS (suddden death syndrome). And we know that SDS has seen a resurregence the last few years with cool and moist weather and is not occurring in more states than ever before (is SCN partly to blame).

With both diseases, their frequence and severity is much greater when SCN is presence in the soil, and the higher the egg count and population the greater the problem. And what is even more serious, according to Malvick is that plant BSR resistance actually seems to be overcome in the presence of SCN.

And SCN enhances early season infection with SDS and overall SDS severity. So with the rapid spread of SCN and buildup of populations with inadequate plant resistance its no wonder that we are seeing more SDS than ever before.

Malvick said the SDS organism lives and overwinters in cysts and can be transported with cysts. However he points out that SCN isn’t required for SDS to develop for it can facilitate rapid spead.

How SCN can transfer SDS to the soybean plant? SCN’s effect is both physical transport and wounding that allows entry into the plant, and like with BSR, SCN might be affecting plant’s resistance to SDS. And Malvick concluded that SCN has helped spread SDS in Minnesota.

Posted at 1:59PM CST 02/04/10 by Dan Davidson
Comments (8)
Dan I'm wondering if there has been any work done on the fact that glyphosate has increased secondary disease, and related symptoms which we keep masking with fungicides and traits, but the real question must be asked when research is done in academia they throughout the anomaly, example; since there was only one yield which was off the charts (soybeans yield at 54 bushels per acre and I trial which hit 85 bushels per acre) they will throughout the 85 bushel per acre since it was not within the parameters. The best one would be when you have 99 plants with disease and one without they throughout the healthy one since that one is the anomaly and they can’t explain it so why try, but when we look at plots we see the anomaly and we want to recreate this to affect yield which is why maybe Kip, Ray, and Keith have went beyond yield which any one of the university experts can explain. When all those PhD went down to Kips, there were a handful of these experts that said Kip had flying saucers over his farm, they can’t explain so they complain? Jeff Littrell N.A.
Posted by Unknown at 8:07AM CST 02/05/10
Mr. N.A., I make the assumption that the aforementioned growers are not using GMO products.
Posted by Aaron R. Ritchie at 8:21AM CST 02/05/10
I not sure but there could be the answer, but that might be a direction to look at.
Posted by Unknown at 8:34AM CST 02/05/10
Jeff, In your trial the varity that was the anomaly, was it non-GMO?
Posted by Aaron R. Ritchie at 8:49AM CST 02/05/10
Over twenty years I've seen it in all aspect Non-GMO, and GMO's
Posted by Unknown at 9:05AM CST 02/05/10
Is that a yes or a no?
Posted by Aaron R. Ritchie at 9:08AM CST 02/05/10
Both, but in resent years GMO a by far the larger problem
Posted by Unknown at 11:06AM CST 02/05/10
Jeff - University folks are largely unwear of Huber's work on glyphosate.
Posted by Daniel Davidson at 12:08PM CST 02/05/10
Post a Blog Comment:
Your Comment:
DTN reserves the right to delete comments posted to any of our blogs and forums, for reasons including profanity, libel, irrelevant personal attacks and advertisements.
Blog Home Pages
July2010
S M T W T F S
            1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Subscribe to Production Blog RSS
Recent Blog Posts
  • Need More Ponies
  • 23-0-0-11Ca
  • My Version of Research
  • Mohawk Roots
  • Robust Yield Check
  • Measuring Soil Health
  • Gave Up
  • Wet Surface means Cooler Canopy
  • The Whole Truth
  • $65 per acre
  • Got Burned
  • Here to Stay
  • Too Late to Spray
  • Planting Late, Should You Inoculate?
  • Glyphosate Inexpensive
  • Field Day Highlights Products
  • Winter Wheat Provides Nesting Habitat
  • Flipping Hats
  • No Sprayer Creates Challenges
  • Rooting Morphology