Ag Policy Blog
Chris Clayton DTN Ag Policy Editor

Friday 03/12/10

The Focus to Bust Up Big Ag

Walking into a meeting Thursday night in Ankeny, Iowa, --- just down the road from where the Department of Justice and USDA will hold today's competition hearing --- it was evident there will be a lot of spotlight on today's hearing. When an unofficial meeting is standing-room only, you can only imagine how many people will be at the official event. Sitting over in a corner was Reuters reporter Carey Gilliam, who wrote as I did that some farm groups want to "Bust Up Big Ag."

http://is.gd/…

It's not hard to imagine who drew the wrath of comments, the largest packers and the dominant company in commercial seed patents. Still if there was any doubt that today's hearing is going to draw a crowd, you can just scan some of the different publications previewing the meeting, including Business Week, the LA Times and New York Times.

Business Week has an article stating that prior court rulings suggest Monsanto's patents in seeds may trump any competition concerns despite the investigations by DOJ and potentially seven state attorneys general.

http://is.gd/…

The LA Times had an article stating "Many experts believe that rising food prices start with seeds." That's because of consolidation in the industry but also complaints about unfair business practices.

"There's a growing sentiment in this White House administration that competition, and the lack of it, is getting to be a serious problem in the food sector," said Neil E. Harl, an Iowa farmer and a retired Iowa State University economics professor (who will speak on one of the panels today). "The question will be whether the government will, after these hearings, take a more active approach."

http://bit.ly/…

The New York Times reported, "During the depths of the economic crisis last year, the prices for many goods held steady or even dropped. But on American farms, the picture was far different, as farmers watched the price they paid for seeds skyrocket. Corn seed prices rose 32 percent; soybean seeds were up 24 percent."

Later in the article the Times writes, "In a recent interview at Monsanto’s headquarters in St. Louis, its chief executive, Hugh Grant, said that while his company might be the market leader, competition was increasing as the era of biotech crops matured.

“We were the first out of the blocks, and I think what you see now is a bunch of people catching up and aggressively competing, and I’m fighting with them,” Mr. Grant said. He said farmers chose the company’s products because they liked the results in the field, not because of any untoward conduct on Monsanto’s part.

http://nyti.ms/…

I can be found on Twitter at chrisclaytonDTN

Posted at 5:50AM CST 03/12/10 by Chris Clayton
Comments (2)
Wrong place to hold the meeting. Those Iowans have sure gone "entitlement crazy"....blue, blue, blue. THE GOVERNMENT NEVER HELPS REDUCE YOUR BOTTOM-LINE COSTS...ONLY THE CONTRARY.
Posted by david nuelle at 9:45AM CST 03/12/10
YEAH!!!!! Finally farmers with back bone!!!!!! Its time we get corporations off our back. As far as blue vs. red I guess the GOP defends corporate lobbies more so and that is their "freedom"??? Competition needs to return to agriculture, I can remember when there were many more companies to buy from and sell to, now there is only the corporate store of Monsanto, Cargil, ADM.....
Posted by Jay Mcginnis at 3:03PM CST 03/12/10
Post a Blog Comment:
Your Comment:
DTN reserves the right to delete comments posted to any of our blogs and forums, for reasons including profanity, libel, irrelevant personal attacks and advertisements.
Blog Home Pages
July2010
S M T W T F S
            1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Subscribe to Ag Policy Blog RSS
Recent Blog Posts
  • Ag Groups Can't Back NCBA Restructuring Plans
  • Senator Questions Cost-Benefit of GIPSA Rule
  • Nebraska Farmers Union Case for Cap and Trade
  • Putting a Lid on Cap and Trade
  • USDA to Announce CRP Signup
  • EPA in Another Dust Up
  • Climate Debate: At The Table or On The Menu
  • Vilsack Apologizes to Fired USDA Worker
  • USDA at Heart of Viral Media Story
  • GIPSA Rule Draws Bi-Partisan Fire
  • R-CALF Busy Defending Proposed Livestock Rule
  • Yankee Boss Highlights Estate Tax Folly
  • USDA Hosting Climate Adaptation Conference
  • Climate Still Tough For Energy Bill, Even With Biofuels
  • CropLife Hosts Farm Bill Forum Webcast
  • Harkin Asks About Legality of Agent Payment Caps
  • FAPRI Chews on Climate Bill Numbers
  • Infrastructure Lacking Attention in Congress
  • NPPC Needs More Time on Competition Rule
  • Soil Scientist: Ag Carbon is Undervalued