DTN/The Progressive Farmer: Agriculture Markets, News and Weather

DTN Ag Policy Blog

Chris Clayton DTN Ag Policy Editor

Bio | Email

Wednesday Nov 11, 2009

Climate Not Changing in Senate

Every day it seems a story comes across the news wire stating that the Senate is not going to pass a climate bill this year.

If I could repeat that, the Senate is not going to pass a climate bill in 2009, OK?

And yet, every day we get a story written as if this is beyond comprehension, only to have a quote from another senator restating the obvious.

"It's common understanding that climate-change legislation will not be brought up on the Senate floor and pass the Senate this year," Senate Finance Chairman Max Baucus, D., Mont., told Dow Jones Newswires.

Baucus said he planned to hold a number of hearings on climate legislation and eventually mark up a bill in his panel. "But I don't know that I can get a bill put together by this year, as important as climate-change legislation is," he said.

Baucus and the Senate Finance Committee held a hearing on jobs on Tuesday. A good summary and some comments can be found at www.farmpolicy.com

Yet, there are people still trying to push a late climate bill. They operate much like a coach on one of those 1-7 NFL teams trying to rally the team to keep playing. Or a fan of one of those teams who for some crazy reason keeps watching them. But I don't know anybody like that.

United Nations General Secretary Ban Ki-moon, on Tuesday was the latest to ask the U.S. Senate to pass a climate bill before UN talks on climate in December.

"From what I heard today, there is great support in the Senate for action on climate change," Ban Ki-moon was quoted saying in Associated Press. "I would sincerely hope that the Senate would take necessary action as soon as possible."

His plea makes the second time in as many weeks a world leader has showed up at the Capitol asking for action. Germany Chancellor Angela Merkel made the same case last week.

While the House has passed a climate bill, it was by the thinnest of margins, one to be exact. It passed with 219 votes and needed 218. In an interview last week, House Agriculture Committee Chairman Collin Peterson, D-Minn., author of the House climate bill agricultural amendment, dubbed, the Peterson amendment, told Environment & Energy Daily he would vote against a final bill, even though he voted for the House version.

Peterson told E&E "he considers his work on the bill done: He has no interest in working to advance climate legislation further," the article stated.

"Do I care? No," he said of the bill's passage.

Food Fight

The Guardian in England is looking this week at the "fight over the future of food" which examines the conflicts of demands for higher food production and need for a new "Green Revolution," in contrast to resistance in some countries to biotechnology. That includes growing resistance to technology in the United States as well.

http://www.mg.co.za/…

I can be found on Twitter at chrisclaytonDTN.

Posted at 07:01AM CST Nov 11, 2009 by Chris Clayton

Comments (2)

Chris: This is very informative material, especially the change of heart being displayed by Representative Peterson. Do you have any insight as to why Mr. Peterson has changed his view on this? His "Do I care? No" statement is particularly perplexing. Could it be that the House is losing interest in the whole concept of climate change and "cap and trade" in light of the continued weakness in the economy? Are they beginning to see how this system of cap and trade would negatively affect the overall economy, including agriculture? Thanks for the good information.

Posted by tom vogel at 07:56AM CST Nov 12, 2009

The climate change models are bunk. Climate change modeling started with the Club of Rome in their 1974 book promoting the running out of resources too many people thesis. Computer modeling is only as good as the underlying assumptions of the model. All models fail becauce their developers fall in love with their work and all the models are simplistic projections from past data used to predict into the future. Secondly, computer models lack a track record. How in the world can world governments fall for conclusions formed by unknown scientists breaking ground in a new field. Third, who elected this group of highly educated scientists to form a world government? They are accountable to whom? Einstein used theoritical mathamatics (whatever that is) not computers to discover laws of the universe. Of course he had a high IQ. Almost half of the USA citizens say the world is cooling. The other half say it is warming. Don't these nuts have enough to argue about with abortion and gay marriage? No now the nuts want to add a third issue, global (maybe) warming.

Posted by DAVE CAPEK at 02:51PM CST Nov 14, 2009

Post a Blog Comment:

Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment. If you are not already registered, click on the Register link at the top of this page.

Post Comment

Blog Home Pages

	November 2009
S	M	T	W	T	F	S
1	2 GOP Ranking Members Caution Boxer on Climate Bill Classifying Carbon Subsidies in Trade	3 Farm Bureau Opposes House Health Care Bill	4 Soybean Growers Spell Out Climate Bill Concerns	5 Climate, Windmills and Checkoffs on the Agenda	6 NFU Urges Passage of Health Care Bill	7
8	9 Rules Coming for SURE	10	11 Climate Not Changing in Senate	12	13 Senators on Allowances, Obama in Japan	14
15	16 USDA, DOJ Meetings Set	17 Lincoln Gearing up For 2010 Campaign Oklahoma Pushes Wind Revolution	18 Biofuel Policies on the Table in December	19 Farm Bureau Praises Delays on Climate Bill	20 Growth Energy Wants CA Carbon Rule Revisited	21
22	23	24	25	26	27	28
29	30

RSS

Recent Blog Posts

Growth Energy Wants CA Carbon Rule Revisited

Fri Nov 20, 2009 03:01 PM CST
Growth Energy states the group has uncovered some documents that suggest the California Air Resources Board ignored some data and comments from its own consultants when the board wrote rules for a new low-carbon fuels standard.

Farm Bureau Praises Delays on Climate Bill

Thu Nov 19, 2009 08:21 AM CST
With statements now from more senators than you can shake a stick at saying that the climate bill cannot pass in 2009, American Farm Bureau President Bob Stallman released a statement praising lawmakers for delaying the climate legislation that the AFBF opposed.

Biofuel Policies on the Table in December

Wed Nov 18, 2009 09:06 AM CST
Some major biofuel policies will come to a head in December as the EPA has to make a decision on E-15 and lawmakers have to decide if some tax credits, such as one for biodiesel, should be extended.

Lincoln Gearing up For 2010 Campaign

Tue Nov 17, 2009 02:43 PM CST
The Senate Agriculture Committee plans to hold a hearing in Arkansas next week as the committee's chairman gears up for what could be a tough election campaign as she walks a moderate line on issues such as health-care reform and climate change.

Oklahoma Pushes Wind Revolution

Tue Nov 17, 2009 09:20 AM CST
I came across a website for a wind conference in Oklahoma, which is interesting because I was certain that people in Oklahoma had no interest in green energy. Also, raw milk sales are becoming one of the latest trends but laws differ from state-to-state, the New York Times reports.

USDA, DOJ Meetings Set

Mon Nov 16, 2009 09:14 AM CST
On Friday USDA and the U.S. Department of Justice announced a 2010 schedule for workshops focusing on competition in agriculture. The plan is for all-day workshops in Iowa, Alabama, Wisconsin, Colorado, and Washington, D.C.

Senators on Allowances, Obama in Japan

Fri Nov 13, 2009 07:05 AM CST
A group of Democratic senators wrote a letter Thursday to other fellow Democratic leaders letting them know that changes have to be made to create more fairness in pollution allowances in the climate bill. Meanwhile, the president is in Asia issuing joint statements with officials about the commitment the U.S. has to addressing climate change.

Climate Not Changing in Senate

Wed Nov 11, 2009 07:01 AM CST
Senators keep telling reporters in Washington that a climate bill will not pass this year, and they keep writing it. Still, some world leaders keep showing up in Washington hoping for action.

Rules Coming for SURE

Mon Nov 9, 2009 08:50 AM CST
USDA sent proposed final rules last week on the SURE disaster program to the White House Office of Management and Budget for review. A USDA spokesman said the department expects rules to be finalized in a matter of weeks.

NFU Urges Passage of Health Care Bill

Fri Nov 6, 2009 09:18 AM CST
Again, the American Farm Bureau Federation and National Farmers Union have taken opposite views on major policy issues being debated in Congress. Much like the differing views on climate change, AFBF and NFU have gone the opposite direction on the health-care bill that could be voted on as early as Friday in the House.

Climate, Windmills and Checkoffs on the Agenda

Thu Nov 5, 2009 03:58 PM CST
This whole week has been strange for climate legislation and the upcoming United Nation's meeting in Copenhagen, Denmark, in December. Besides the Republican boycott, three other senators began running around trying to get rally caps on for the bill as if there was some practical way to actually get a climate bill passed this year.

Soybean Growers Spell Out Climate Bill Concerns

Wed Nov 4, 2009 12:18 PM CST
The American Soybean Association on Wednesday issued a paper outlining its concerns and issues for climate change legislation.

Farm Bureau Opposes House Health Care Bill

Tue Nov 3, 2009 03:26 PM CST
The American Farm Bureau Federation released a statement Tuesday from AFBF President Bob Stallman that urged all members of the House to oppoe the House health care bill that could see a floor vote as early as Thursday.

GOP Ranking Members Caution Boxer on Climate Bill

Mon Nov 2, 2009 04:00 PM CST
Ranking Republicans on six Senate committees cautioned Senate Environment and Public Works Chairman Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., from pushing to write the climate bill in her committee without better analysis or addressing the concerns of other senators in both parties.

Classifying Carbon Subsidies in Trade

Sun Nov 1, 2009 07:04 PM CST
One area of focus related to agriculture and climate change will come after the United Nations meeting in Copenhagen, Denmark, but likely to generate a great deal of debate in coming years: How are carbon incentives or "subsidies" going to be classified under the World Trade Organization?

NFU Balances Out Climate Arguments

Fri Oct 30, 2009 05:54 AM CDT
The American Farm Bureau Federation got the opportunity to testify before Senate Environment and Public Works Committee this week in opposition to the Senate climate bill but Democrats did not invite a farm group backing the legislation to balance out arguments

Climate Notes From Tuesday

Tue Oct 27, 2009 07:52 PM CDT
One element that came out of Tuesday's hearing with the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee hearing is the idea that the Environmental Protection Agency could use new legislation for the major greenhouse-gas emitting industries, yet want to preserve the authority of the Clean Air Act for other industries.

Climate Focus Begins in Senate

Tue Oct 27, 2009 07:03 AM CDT
While we are waiting on the Senate Agriculture Committee to lay down a marker on climate legislation, Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich., is taking a lead on possible agriculture provisions that could go into the bill.

A Few Minor Scheduling Issues in Washington

Fri Oct 23, 2009 08:40 AM CDT
Just in case you miss it, there's a lot of stuff going on this week in Washington. There's so much stuff in fact that I wish some of these people had consulted with the press before booking it all, especially since some of us have head colds.

Writing About Infrastructure

Fri Oct 23, 2009 08:40 AM CDT
DTN spent the last three days running a series I wrote on rural infrastructure, sort of a follow-up to a larger series we ran a little more than a year ago. After spending several weeks reporting for the series I can declare pretty simply that rural infrastructure is just not what people want to read about.