Minding Ag's Business

Defend Against Reversals of Fortune

Given the abrupt drop in commodity prices this year, "the solvency of some farm customers could shift quickly," David Lynn, a senior vice president for Farm Credit Mid-America cautioned ag economists attending a conference in Louisville this month.

Indeed, University of Illinois economists now estimates 2014 gross revenues in northern Illinois will run about $300/acre below the 2011-2013 average of $1,100/acre. That's even counting robust yields, which won't totally compensate for the steep collapse in corn prices this season. Projections for 2015 look worse, although it's still early in the process.

Lynn urges his association's 97,000 farm customers to be proactive about this reversal of fortune and to develop habits that will persuade lenders they remain good long-term risks, even if potential 2014 and 2015 losses reflect a temporary setback.

One grower he visited recently opted to let a farm go in another state in 2014 because the cash rents were excessive in relation to current commodity prices. Simply put the rent exceeded the grower's threshold for what he felt he could pay as a percentage of the gross income per acre while providing a satisfactory return. "Lenders like to see producers maintain that flexibility with their operations," Lynn says. Among his recommendations:

P[L1] D[0x0] M[300x250] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]

--Develop a five-year plan for your business. While there's much uncertainty in the farm economy, set goals for your operation. Plan for 2019 now.

--Put your farm financials through contingency plans for multiple scenarios. For example, what happens if the season-average corn price is $3.10 instead of $3.70?

--Communicate your succession plan. If you don't have a family member following in your footsteps, what is your horizon and your exit strategy?

--Always look for opportunity. Rapid change creates opportunity.

--Prepare cash flows for multiple events, such as an increase in interest rates and lower grain prices in 2015. "Ten-year T-bills are as low as any time since World War II," he says. "We think rates will stay that way through the end of the year, then start to climb in 2015. They could be up 200 or 300 basis points in 24 to 36 months, but they would still be among the lowest rates ever."

--Establish adequate working capital. That likely means setting a line of credit in advance of when you need it. Many farmers fail to understand the importance of properly balancing short-term, intermediate and long-term debt. "During times of strong farm earnings producers often use their cash to pay for short- and intermediate-term assets and to pay off long-term debt," he says. "Within 24-36 months, if there is significant stress on farm income, they may experience a cash flow crunch and thus their financials may stressed in regards to extending more credit."

--Fix interest rates for the term of your loan. Besides fixed-rate mortgages, FCS Mid-America is currently offering one-year fixed rates on operating line of credits as low as 2.99%. Historically, the average operating rate is closer to 6% to 8%. "When rates start to rise, it's too late to take advantage because markets move too fast," he says.

--Manage risk with forward pricing and crop insurance. In the drought of 2012, 93% of FCS Mid-America's customers triggered crop insurance claims. "It's an even more important risk management tool in times like this since it provides certainty and confidence in planting decisions," Lynn says. "It helps insure that farmers can recoup their input costs."

As an example, in Christian County, Ky., it cost about $525 per acre for corn input costs, versus $20 to $25 per acre for crop insurance. Lynn says, "That's 4% to 5% of input costs, so from a farm lender perspective, the question is how can you not?"

Follow me on Twitter@MarciaZTaylor

P[] D[728x170] M[320x75] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]
P[L2] D[728x90] M[320x50] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]

Comments

To comment, please Log In or Join our Community .

James Pritchett
1/20/2015 | 2:54 PM CST
FARMERS WON'T STOP FEEDING THE WORLD. SHADES OF 1979
James Pritchett
1/20/2015 | 2:51 PM CST
FARMERS WON'T STOP FEEDING THE WORLD.
Freeport IL
10/22/2014 | 4:26 PM CDT
Sometimes interesting insights are provided by trying to answer a stupid question. The question was; "What needs to happen for corn yield protection crop insurance (YP) to equal a corn harvest option revenue product (RA) in Northwestern Illinois?)" A lot of assumptions were needed to provide our outcomes. We tried to narrow the variables to spring insurance price and US planted corn acres. We assumed a farm yield to US yield relationship and an ending corn stocks to price relationship. Beginning balance, imports and use were assumed from the current WASDE report. The conclusions were: 1. For the harvest option price of RA to kick in (trigger), the farm yields need to be at the same yield levels for YP to kick in (trigger). 2. RA always has scenarios were it will have a higher indemnity than YP because there is always a chance for harvest insurance prices to be above spring. 3. For our assumptions, it looks farm yields could drop below 85% of an adjusted APH about 20% of the time. RA looks to have an indemnity above YP and its additional premium 75% of those times YP is triggered. A scenario with the lowest possibility of an indemnity occurs with low planted acres and a low spring price. RA's indemnity minus premium will net more than YP at least 15% of the time (20% X 75% = 15%) with above price outlook. RA with harvest price exclusion rarely to never have an indemnity in this low chance of an indemnity scenario. Those expecting a low spring price with low planted corn acres may want to review their insurance coverage if RA with harvest price exclusion is to be used this coming season. 4. If planted corn acres for the 2015-16 marketing year are north of 90 million acres and spring price is around $4.00 per bushel, there appears to be at least a 40% chance of an indemnity in Northwestern Illinois with the assumption used. Those chances drop to about a 20% minimum chance with a $3.50 price with the same scenario. 5. If corn planted acres come in at 85 million acres both a $4.00 and a $3.50 spring price has a 20% chance of an indemnity. It seems at this chance level of an indemnity, the spring price is too low or the assumptions of fall prices are too high. This is the scenario were YP may work if price assumptions are close to being correct. The same could be said for $3.50 on 90 million spring acres. When looking for places to reduce cost this coming growing season, your crop insurance decision appears to hinge on the relationship of the spring insurance price against the expected fall harvest price. The challenge, in part, becomes guessing the number of acres planted to corn this spring. Spring planted acres will be a large factor in fall prices. The USDA releases the spring acreage estimate after our crop insurance decisions are made. So fall expected price is very much a guess at insurance sign up. If spring price feels high for the expected fall price, RA with the harvest price exclusion might save some premium and provide some revenue protection. With this choice, one needs to acknowledge a high fall price may make this choice worthless. If springs price feels low for the expected fall price, YP could have the same trigger yield as RA. With this choice, one needs to acknowledge RA with harvest options will, most of the time, net a higher indemnity. One needs to weigh the higher premium and lower chance of indemnity with this scenario against the higher net payout - when it occurs. At least for Northwestern Illinois and barring an extreme spring price compared to expected fall price, the highest level of RA one has used in the past seems reasonable. Freeport, IL