Minding Ag's Business
Marcia Zarley Taylor DTN Executive Editor

Tuesday 12/15/09

Buckle Up for Turbulence

Despite one of the worst Midwest blizzards in 30 years, more than 425 farmers and agribusiness leaders gathered in Chicago last week for the third annual DTN-Progressive Farmer's Ag Summit. The turbulence we were discussing wasn't due to snow drifts on Interstate 80, it was stomach churning swings in weather, commodity prices, government policy, fertilizer and fuel prices that marked crop year 2009 and will mean more disparity between the haves and have nots when this year's profits are tallied. Consider some of the speakers' highlights:

Hope isn't a strategy for managing risks, reminded Allan Gray, director of Purdue University's Center for Food and Agriculture. Yet a minority of farmers regularly use management tools like options or futures (18 to 35 percent, with bigger farmers using them more often), and only 53 to 74 percent even forward price their production (again tilting in favor of bigger operators).

Even then, commodity markets don't always offer profit opportunities: The 26-month fallout in the pork sector is the "longest period of negative returns in hogs since the early 1980s," he noted, requiring operators to dig deep into their working capital and lifetime equity

Higher input costs--up about 85 percent for corn growers in 2009 vs. the previous five-year average--actually expose growers to more risk than ever, he added. Farm safety nets like Counter Cyclical Payments and target prices actually do little to buffer losses today, since they haven't kept pace with higher breakeven costs, he stressed. "The government program used to do a great job of taking care of us when prices were low, but not today," Gray said. "Programs didn't go away, they're just not very effective."

All farm lenders are beginning to absorb loan losses now, and that will make them more cautious credit providers in the year ahead, warned Donnie Winters, CEO of Farm Credit Services of Mid-America in Louisville. Pure grain operations haven't been impacted much yet, but livestock operations are in a different world, he said.

Going forward, lenders won't just size up your risk in simple total debt-to-total asset ratios, Winters said. Instead, they'll dwell on debt-to-income measures like debt per cow, sow or tillable acre to assess your long-term survivability. Some dairies have accumulated losses of over $7,000 or more per cow, for example. They'll be challenged to compete with those with more normal $3,000 per cow debts. On the other hand, those now buying bankrupt ethanol plants at 95 cents-per gallon capacity should have a leg up on the bulk of plants that are operating at $1.50 per gallon debt. For some second owners, the lower investment costs offer real competitiveness.

Climate changes are likely to continue to torment Grain Belt growers with more extreme weather patterns that could encourage pests and impact yields, observed Jerry Hatfield, director of the Agricultural Research Service's Ames, Iowa laboratory and a Nobel Peace Prize contributor. He foresees a period of wetter springs and more intense but infrequent rainfall. Those storm patterns mean farmers need to defend their top soil with more stover and biomass. But there are fringe benefits to building organic matter: Adding 1 percent organic matter to Iowa soils increased corn yields 16 bu. per acre, or about $64 an acre per year. "That's more than the price of carbon," he said.

Farming isn't all about money; sometimes it's just a reminder that businessmen need to exercise their conscience as well as their wallets. Farmer-philanthropist Howard Buffett, son of Berkshire-Hathaway Chairman Warren Buffett, uses autosteer and SWATH technology on his Illinois farm like the best U.S. farm operator. But solving Africa's food insecurity will require more than high technology, he told the crowd. "The strategy should not be to take the poorest people in the world and hook them on fossil fuel technology they can't afford," he said.

Instead, his foundation has already given away $150 million to improve seed and farming techniques for small stakeholders, usually women farming one or two acre plots. They aren't focused on yields, he says, they focus on a diversified crop mix so that if one fails, they have enough food to last until the next harvest. "These people don't have a recession, because they don't have a possession to lose," he said.

Buffett could have been spending Christmas in Palm Beach or playing golf, living the life of the idle rich. He could have simply written a check to his favorite charities. Instead he was headed for an African civil war zone, where hungry people really needed him, putting body on soul on the line.

Posted at 5:16PM CST 12/15/09 by Marcia Zarley Taylor
Comments (3)
Marcia: In all due respect, you and the informants give the impression that weather, prices, and market uncertainty are something new facing farmers and agribusiness people. These same points could have been made each year for the last two centuries. Climate change? Can you imagine the "climate change" that occurred in the 1930s? Marcia, these are the same types of challenges that generations have faced, and today we actually have more tools than ever to deal with them - i.e. crop insurance, futures, and whatnot. I think we should spend more time on managing our business risks as opposed to lamenting threats that have been there since the country's founding. I am in the grain business I believe that with these tools this is the best time ever to be in agriculture. In fact, I am looking to expand again this year...for the seventh time in the last eight years! I am not lamenting risk...I am managing risk, while owning the finest asset in the world - US farmland!
Posted by tom vogel at 8:57AM CST 12/16/09
Tom, I agree risk is part of a farmer's job description, but you have to admit that the there's more of it today than any time in recent history. According to the CME Group, the price swing in the 2008 corn crop was twice the average of the past 25 years, and 2009 was little better. The $500 per ton drop in fertilizer this year was 10 times the normal $50 per ton mark up fertilizer dealers make, Allan Gray says. So your conclusion is the same as mine: Farmers who can master the risk will flourish in this market. The disconcerting thing is that many part-timers or less serious producers do not forward price their crops or inputs and will expose themselves to bigger income gyrations in the future. Hence my comment that the profit margins will vary widely among farmers this year.
Posted by MARCIA TAYLOR at 10:41AM CST 12/16/09
You are indeed correct Marcia; the price swings are turbulent as can be. One item that I believe is driving this turbulence is the fact that the grains are no longer just a food commodity; they are an energy commodity as well. Depending on whom you believe, somewhere between 25 and 30 percent of the nation's corn crop this year is going to ethanol. That certainly adds demand, which we like, but it also adds volatility, that we may not like but we can manage. I can't speak for the bulk of farmers here in the Midwest, but I can tell that here in Ohio the farmers I know are all managing risk with crop insurance, futures, and hedging. We know our break-even points and we insure to that level and use futures to lock in prices and profits. Some of us actually like the volatility because we can use the upward spikes to lock in contract prices, and I can tell you it has really helped us here in Ohio. With good prices (not great, but good) and average yields approaching 200 bushels on corn and 55 on beans, we are having a superb year in Ohio, even with a late harvest. The key is learning how to capitalize on volatility and manage risk.
Posted by tom vogel at 8:15PM CST 12/16/09
Post a Blog Comment:
Your Comment:
DTN reserves the right to delete comments posted to any of our blogs and forums, for reasons including profanity, libel, irrelevant personal attacks and advertisements.
Blog Home Pages
July2010
S M T W T F S
            1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Subscribe to Minding Ag's Business RSS
Recent Blog Posts
  • Time is Ticking on Tax Time Bomb
  • Stampede to Refinance
  • Can Estate Tax Reform Save the Last Farm?
  • Guilty on Fuel Buys?
  • What's Wrong With ACRE?
  • VIP Farms Tilt Global Grain Markets
  • In Former Soviet Union, Converting Capitalists is Harder Than We Think
  • Investors Seek Safe Haven in Farmland
  • Aren't Farm Programs Worthless Anyway?
  • Think of ACRE as a Cheap Option
  • Ask the ACRE Specialists
  • Rethink Antipathy Toward ACRE
  • Agri Europe's Green Challenge
  • Biotech in Belgium
  • "Smart" Money's Infatuation With Farmland
  • Bounce Left in Land Values
  • Picking Sides On Health Insurance
  • IRS Targets CRP Rents
  • Test Drive Brazil on Cheap Cash Rent
  • Last Minute Crop Insurance Tips