Ag Weather Forum
Bryce Anderson DTN Ag Meteorologist and DTN Analyst

Wednesday 11/07/12

Post-Sandy Forecast Controversy

I posted a blog item last week on the way that Hurricane Sandy focused attention on a lag in performance of the U.S. weather forecast model compared to the European model--but this is a big enough subject that it's worth another look. Following is a link to an article by Politico that has more detail on the deficiencies in development--and yes, funding $$$--that the "Sandy" event exposed. Here is the introduction:

Sandy is calling new attention to a long-running debate about whether the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is getting the money and resources it needs to track and predict life-threatening storms.

Yes, NOAA’s National Hurricane Center nailed the forecast track four days out, projecting that the ferocious storm would slam into the New Jersey coast and giving officials time to warn of deadly flooding and wind.

But some wonder if the public could have gotten warning even earlier.

http://tinyurl.com/…

Bryce

I'm on Twitter http://twitter.com/…

(CZ/SK)

Posted at 10:00AM CST 11/07/12 by Bryce Anderson
Comments (2)
So where are the blogs or write-ups from these ecmwf worshippers when that model turns out to be wrong or caves to the gfs? The gfs is a good model but it has it's flaws and so does the ecmwf. 4-5 day warning time should give the public plenty of time to take notice and prepare. I think it's foolish to base a forecast off one model 7 + days out as many times the forecast turns out to be wrong. Kudos to the euro with sandy but credit should be given to the cmc also.
Posted by Rick S at 8:00AM CST 11/08/12
Thanks for the comment Rick. I think that the aspect of satellite outage concerns is possibly as important an issue as model performance. And yes, 4-5 days out for a call on the landfall of Sandy did offer more lead time than we have seen in other hurricane instances.
Posted by Bryce Anderson at 1:18PM CST 11/08/12
Post a Blog Comment:
Your Comment:
DTN reserves the right to delete comments posted to any of our blogs and forums, for reasons including profanity, libel, irrelevant personal attacks and advertisements.
Blog Home Pages
May  2015
S M T W T F S
               1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31                  
Subscribe to Ag Weather Forum RSS
Recent Blog Posts
  • Drier Weather Continues for Canadian Prairies
  • Crop Report And Pattern Comments
  • NOAA: Mild Summer Forecast
  • Drought Outlook Mostly Favorable
  • Dry for Some, Wetter for Others in Prairies
  • Northern Highs Are Still Around
  • El Nino Signals Rival 1997
  • Early Emerged Crops in Prairies May be Threatened by Cold
  • Australia Declares El Nino
  • Australia SOI Tilts Toward El Nino
  • Too Much, Enough, or Too Little?
  • Favorable Weather for Prairie Seeding
  • 2015 Versus 2010
  • Weather Forecast Favors Upcoming Seeding
  • April Chills And Planting
  • Differing Soil Moisture Conditions for Western Canada
  • U.S. Corn Yields Projected Above Trend Line With El Nino Onset
  • El Nino And Above-Trend Yields
  • Rainfall Continues to be Light for the Prairies
  • Crop Report And Weather Comments