Minding Ag's Business
Marcia Zarley Taylor DTN Executive Editor

Thursday 10/24/13

When You Are Your Brother's Keeper

A recent Iowa Supreme Court ruling reminds farmland heirs to play fair in love and business, as DTN's Elizabeth Williams reported in "Sometimes Minority Rules" last week.

Yes, your grandparents may have intended inherited land to stay in family hands for generations, if possible. Yes, it's difficult to dissolve farmland trapped inside a 1960s C Corporation. But CPAs, family business mediators and attorneys tell us that increasingly courts are taking a jaundiced view of business partners who fail to pay dividends or set reasonable buy-sell terms when family partners want to leave the business.

The case of Baur v. Baur Farms highlights many common problems when land passes to second- or third-generation owners, says Nick Houle, a CPA who specializes in estate and small business transition planning for CliftonLarsonAllen LLP in Minneapolis.

In the Baur case, the off-farm heir complained he was nearing 80 years old and before he died, he wanted to cash in on the family farm he been gifted and inherited in the 1980s. Over that period, he had received no cash rent, no dividends and could come to no agreement on a price for the family's jointly-owned land that had ballooned in value since its 1980s book value.

"People feel so strongly that they want to keep family holdings intact that they sometimes forget that minority shareholders have rights, too," he says. On the other hand, exiting partners forget that if they happen to own land in a C corporation, the corporation could first owe as much as 35% on any capital gains, then shareholders are taxed as much as another 20%. That leaves them 52% of the gross gain if they're paying the highest rates, not counting extra damages from state taxes, Houle says. "It's not a good answer."

A better structure would be for farm families to own land inside an S Corporation or LLC. In that case, they'd pay only 20% federal capital gains when land is sold. "We also recommend paying cash rents at the average rates for their counties," Houle says. That's evidence that rates are fair, gives all owners a share of the land's profits and can keep families out of court.

Lance Woodbury, a Garden City, Kan., certified mediator and farm family business adviser, reminds families that it pays to treat all partners inclusively. "Even though someone is a minority shareholder, their 'power' is not just financial ... their real power is in the ability to create challenges to the status quo," he says. "The lesson being that the effort to create a sense of shared psychological ownership (agreement about direction, exit strategies, etc.) pays some dividends in that it helps prevents these kind of disputes."

Houle and Woodbury will be including a discussion of this case--along with other model farm estate practices-- at DTN's "Pass It On!" estate planning workshop Dec. 8 in Chicago. Last year it was our highest rated session of the four-day Ag Summit, with high praise for getting your technical questions answered.

For more information on DTN's four-hour, small group course, "Pass It On!" with Nick Houle and Family Business Mediator Lance Woodbury, go to DTN University at www.dtnagsummit.com

For Elizabeth Williams' story, "Sometime Minority Rules," go to http://www.dtnprogressivefarmer.com/…

Follow me on Twitter@MarciaZTaylor


Posted at 10:39AM CDT 10/24/13 by Marcia Zarley Taylor
Comments (1)
Correction: Actually the double taxation for C Corp shareholders is slightly worse than 35% plus 20%. We forgot to add the new 3.8% surcharge on investment income, so the combined damages would be 35% corporate tax, plus 23.8% for the individual. Net result is you'd take home less than HALF of any farmland appreciation in a C Corp, BEFORE state income taxes. If you need ideas on how to unwind a C Corp, see Elizabeth Williams' excellent article "Avoid the Land Trap" in the November issue of The Progressive Farmer magazine and/or join us in Chicago!
Posted by Marcia Taylor at 11:02AM CDT 10/25/13
Post a Blog Comment:
Your Comment:
DTN reserves the right to delete comments posted to any of our blogs and forums, for reasons including profanity, libel, irrelevant personal attacks and advertisements.
Blog Home Pages
April  2014
      1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30         
Subscribe to Minding Ag's Business RSS
Recent Blog Posts
  • Not 1979 All Over Again
  • The Great ARC or PLC Debate
  • Farm Incomes Bounce from Feast to Famine
  • Keep Family Legends Alive
  • Russian Grain Embargo in Retrospect
  • The Russians (And Others) Are Coming
  • Why Seniors Keep a Grip on Land
  • Teach Kids Respect for Paper Wealth
  • Something's Gotta Give on 2014 Expenses
  • Why Crop Insurance Can't Fly Solo
  • Tax Reform Not Simple
  • Picking PLC or ARC?
  • No Substitute for Staying Low Cost
  • Put '14 Crop Insurance on Auto Pilot
  • Another Obamacare Deadline Eased
  • The Lean Don't Worry About $4 Corn
  • Pay Limits and Burden of Proof
  • More Punishment for Small Employers
  • Depreciate or Lease?
  • Avoid Family Feuds